True-crime stories often grip us because they reveal how ordinary lives can suddenly unravel into extraordinary tragedy. One such case is that of Kandi Hall, a paralegal from Idaho whose extramarital affair with attorney Emmett Corrigan led to jealousy, confrontation, and murder.
The tale involves betrayal, courtroom drama, theft, and the destruction of two families. Over a decade later, the case is still revisited in documentaries, news articles, and crime podcasts. It remains one of Idaho’s most infamous true-crime sagas.
In this article, we’ll break down who Kandi Hall is, her role in the scandal, the tragic events of March 2011, the legal aftermath, and why the case continues to attract national attention.
Who Is Kandi Hall?
Kandi Hall was a 40-year-old paralegal living in Meridian, Idaho, at the time of the events. She was married to Robert Hall and raised two daughters. Outwardly, her life appeared typical, but beneath the surface were marital struggles and financial instability.
Her professional life changed in late 2010 when she began working for an attorney named Emmett Corrigan. What started as a work connection quickly grew into something more personal—and ultimately catastrophic.
Kandi Hall’s Marriage and Family Life
Kandi had been married to Robert Hall for years. The couple appeared stable, but their relationship reportedly had cracks. Robert struggled with trust issues and emotional volatility, while Kandi sought validation outside the marriage.
Together, they had two daughters who would eventually bear the emotional scars of what was to come. The Hall family was far from perfect, but no one could have predicted how dramatically things would unravel.
The Fatal Affair with Emmett Corrigan
Kandi and Emmett’s relationship began innocently enough, with conversations in the office. However, their bond grew quickly, and by late 2010, the two were involved in a secret affair.
Emmett was married to Ashlee Corrigan, with whom he shared five young children. Despite his responsibilities at home, he pursued the relationship with Kandi in secret.
The affair soon consumed their lives, with late-night phone calls, secret meetings, and increasing emotional involvement. By early 2011, it was clear the affair was not just physical but deeply personal, and the risks of exposure grew.
Walgreens Parking Lot Murder
The turning point came on March 11, 2011. That evening, Kandi met Emmett at a Walgreens parking lot in Meridian. They briefly left to be intimate in Emmett’s truck before returning to the lot.
Unbeknownst to them, Robert Hall had been following. He arrived armed with a handgun. Witnesses recalled a heated argument before Robert shot Emmett multiple times, killing him instantly.
Robert then turned the gun on himself, inflicting a non-fatal wound to his head. The scene shocked the community, transforming a quiet suburban night into a national headline.
Robert Hall’s Trial and Conviction
Robert Hall survived his self-inflicted wound and was charged with second-degree murder. His trial revealed intimate details about Kandi’s affair with Emmett and the events that led to the confrontation.
The prosecution argued Robert acted deliberately, while the defense insisted he snapped in the heat of the moment. Despite his claims of emotional turmoil, Robert was found guilty.
He was sentenced to 30 years in prison, with parole eligibility around 2028. The trial left both families devastated, with the Corrigans grieving Emmett’s loss and the Halls grappling with Robert’s imprisonment.
Kandi Hall’s Legal Troubles After the Murder
Though Kandi was never charged in Emmett’s death, she faced her own legal consequences. Just two months after the shooting, she was arrested for grand theft after investigators found she had embezzled funds from her former employer.
She pleaded guilty and was sentenced to nearly two years in prison. After release, she was placed on probation, which extends until 2026.
Kandi’s conviction added another layer of scandal to an already infamous case.
Media Coverage and True Crime Spotlight
The sensational details of the affair and murder attracted national media attention. The case was featured on Dateline: Deadly Desire and Investigation Discovery, with reenactments and interviews exploring the emotional and legal fallout.
Audiences were fascinated by the mix of suburban normalcy, betrayal, and explosive violence. For true-crime fans, the story became emblematic of how hidden secrets can destroy families.
Kandi Hall and Public Perception
Public opinion about Kandi Hall remains divided. Some view her as a woman trapped in a troubled marriage who sought escape in a dangerous affair. Others believe her choices directly contributed to the tragedy.
Her theft conviction reinforced negative perceptions. For many, she became a cautionary example of how deception and poor judgment can ruin lives.
The Life of Emmett Corrigan
Emmett was a 30-year-old attorney and father of five at the time of his death. He was ambitious, charismatic, and well-liked by colleagues. However, his secret affair undermined his image as a devoted family man.
His murder left behind a grieving wife, Ashlee, who was suddenly responsible for raising their children alone. In later interviews, she spoke about resilience, forgiveness, and the ongoing impact of that night.
Robert Hall’s Life Behind Bars
Robert Hall has now served over a decade of his 30-year sentence. Reports suggest he has adapted to prison life but continues to carry the burden of his actions.
His parole eligibility in 2028 raises questions about whether he will be released and how his family might respond. For the Corrigan family, the thought of Robert’s release remains deeply painful.
Kandi Hall’s Probation and Whereabouts
Since serving her prison sentence for theft, Kandi has remained on probation. She has avoided the spotlight and lives under legal restrictions until 2026.
Her name resurfaces whenever documentaries or news outlets revisit the case, but otherwise, she has largely disappeared from public view.
Key Facts About the Case
- 2010: Affair between Kandi Hall and Emmett Corrigan begins.
- March 11, 2011: Emmett is murdered in Walgreens parking lot.
- 2012: Robert Hall convicted of second-degree murder.
- 2011–2013: Kandi convicted of theft and imprisoned.
- 2014: Kandi released under probation.
- 2026: Probation ends for Kandi Hall.
- 2028: Robert Hall eligible for parole.
Quick Reference Table
| Person | Role in Case | Outcome |
| Kandi Hall | Paralegal, had affair with Corrigan | Convicted of theft, probation until 2026 |
| Emmett Corrigan | Attorney, married father of five | Murdered in 2011 by Robert Hall |
| Robert Hall | Kandi’s husband | Convicted of second-degree murder, serving 30 years |
Timeline of Events
- Late 2010: Kandi and Emmett begin an affair.
- March 11, 2011: Walgreens confrontation and murder.
- 2012: Robert convicted of second-degree murder.
- 2011–2013: Kandi imprisoned for theft.
- 2014: Kandi released on probation.
- 2026: Kandi’s probation is set to end.
- 2028: Robert eligible for parole.
The Families Left Behind
The greatest victims of the case are the children. Emmett’s five children lost their father overnight. Robert and Kandi’s daughters lost the stability of both parents—one in prison, the other disgraced.
The ripple effect continues today, with both families forced to rebuild under difficult circumstances.
Lessons from the Case
The tragedy of Kandi Hall highlights the dangers of secrecy and betrayal. What began as an affair spiraled into murder, imprisonment, and public disgrace.
It also underscores how decisions made in moments of passion or anger can permanently alter lives.
The Lasting True Crime Legacy
The story of Kandi Hall continues to be revisited by true-crime enthusiasts. Its themes of infidelity, jealousy, and murder make it a compelling case study in human behavior.
More than a decade later, it remains one of Idaho’s most infamous scandals.
FAQs
1. Who is Kandi Hall?
Kandi Hall is a former paralegal from Idaho, best known for her affair with attorney Emmett Corrigan and later legal issues involving theft.
2. What happened on March 11, 2011?
That night, Robert Hall confronted his wife Kandi and her lover Emmett in a Walgreens parking lot, fatally shooting Emmett.
3. Was Kandi Hall charged with murder?
No, she was never charged in connection with Emmett’s death.
4. What sentence did Robert Hall receive?
Robert was sentenced to 30 years in prison for second-degree murder, with parole eligibility in 2028.
5. What were Kandi Hall’s legal charges?
She was convicted of theft and embezzlement from her employer and served nearly two years in prison.
6. Where is Kandi Hall today?
She remains on probation until 2026 and has kept a low profile since her release.
7. Why does the case still attract attention?
The mix of infidelity, betrayal, and violent murder makes it one of Idaho’s most infamous true-crime stories, covered extensively in documentaries and media features.
Conclusion
The case of Kandi Hall is more than just a story of infidelity. It’s a cautionary tale of how deception and emotional turmoil can end in irreversible tragedy.
The murder of Emmett Corrigan, the imprisonment of Robert Hall, and Kandi’s own criminal downfall ensure the case remains relevant. For true-crime followers, it continues to embody the devastating consequences of secrets and betrayal.